Utah vs. Idaho: Which is better?

Let’s talk about a Bear Lake debate: Utah side or Idaho side?

Living on either side of Bear Lake has unique advantages for homeowners. Here are a few things to think about when choosing where to buy your Bear Lake Getaway.

The real estate market all around Bear Lake offers a diverse range of properties, from cozy cabins to luxurious lakefront homes. No matter which state you choose, the property values and property taxes are fairly similar. So what makes them different?

On the Utah side, living near Garden City means you have convenient access to dining, shopping, and other amenities. You’ll also find easy access to attractions like Bear Lake Golf Course and Beaver Mountain for recreation and entertainment. Living on the Utah side of Bear Lake also means that the school districts have a higher per-student budget as compared to Idaho; something you may consider if you have school-aged children.

On the Idaho side, while you may have to make the drive to Garden City, UT for some amenities, small towns like St. Charles offer a charming atmosphere and plenty to explore. Attractions such as Minnetonka Cave give you a chance for adventure close by in Idaho, and of course, any of the Utah attractions (Bear Lake Golf Course, Beaver Mountain, etc.) are still just a short drive away. Idaho also boasts lower retirement taxes and lower vehicle registration costs when compared to Utah.

Ultimately, whether you choose the Utah side or the Idaho side of Bear Lake, you'll be surrounded by incredible natural beauty and a welcoming community. This truly is the place to purchase a Getaway. As your real estate expert, I'm here to help you with the nuances of each state and find the perfect place for your Bear Lake Getaway.